Reservation
+1 360-378-5757
Visit Us
248 Reuben Memorial Dr, Friday Harbor, WA 98250, United States
Hello dear
Welcome To McMillin's Dining Room
Nestled in the picturesque Friday Harbor, McMillin's Dining Room offers a culinary experience that delights the senses. With a menu featuring exquisite selections like pan-seared Alaskan scallops and Mama Shaw's homemade meatloaf, each dish showcases the rich flavors of locally-sourced ingredients. Diners frequently rave about the outstanding service and warm ambiance, making it perfect for special occasions. Reviews highlight the scrumptious calamari and perfectly cooked wagyu steak, while the lush surroundings provide a stunning backdrop. McMillin’s skillful blend of culinary artistry and heartfelt hospitality undoubtedly makes it a dining gem on the island, promising memorable meals for both locals and visitors alike.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pan Seared Scallop Risotto
Dungeness Crab Bisque
The Overseer Burger*
Prime Cap Steak*
About
McMillin's Dining Room
Welcome to McMillin's Dining Room, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Friday Harbor, Washington. Located at 248 Reuben Memorial Dr, this exquisite dining locale invites you to embark on a gastronomic journey filled with unforgettable flavors and remarkable service. The elegant atmosphere and stunning views create a perfect backdrop for both intimate dinners and celebratory gatherings.
McMillin's stands out with a thoughtfully curated menu that showcases the best of local and seasonal ingredients. Start your meal with delectable appetizers such as the Pan Seared Scallop Risotto featuring Alaskan Weathervane scallops paired with creamy risotto and a hint of bacon onion relish, or indulge in the earthy flavors of Guemes Island Mushroom Sauté complete with local goat cheese and freshly baked focaccia. For lovers of seafood, the Crispy Calamari lightly dusted with almonds and served with lemon aioli is a must-try, perfectly balancing texture and flavor.
As you explore the fresh salads and bisques, the Caesar Salad with Charred Tomatoes offers a traditional yet innovative take with its aromatic Caesar vinaigrette and hand-torn croutons, while the vibrant Spinach and Baby Kale Salad garnished with a tender poached egg adds a wholesome touch to your dining experience.
For the main course, the culinary team delights with offerings like Mama Shaw's Homemade Meatloaf, a comforting blend of beef, pork, and lamb enhanced by a mushroom demi-glace and paired with Yukon Gold mashed potatoes – a nostalgic dish elevated by quality ingredients. Seafood enthusiasts will be enthralled by the Wild Alaskan Coho Salmon, which is impeccably pan-seared and complemented with a medley of wild grains, bringing together a melody of tastes and textures.
Don't overlook dessert; the Blackberry Cobbler has earned rave reviews, proving a sweet finale to rounds of exquisite dining.
Customer experiences at McMillin's further underscore the excellence of this establishment. Guests like Nicole Bell and Erick Walker praised not only the exceptional food quality but also the attentiveness of the staff who go above and beyond to ensure every detail is perfect. The reviews highlight memorable occasions, from birthdays to proposals, all enriched by the inviting service and a stunning ambiance.
McMillin's Dining Room is more than just a place to eat; it's a celebration of food and camaraderie, making it an essential stop for anyone visiting the San Juan Islands. Whether you're here for a special celebration or a casual dinner, prepare for a culinary experience that will leave you craving more. With every visit, you'll find yourself yearning to return to this delightful haven of flavor and hospitality.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Literally the best meal I have had in years. We were a party of six and got a bit of everything. Not only was it cooked to perfection but the flavors were unmatched. We were visiting from Orlando, FL and this place ran circles around many of the fine dining places we visit at home. The calamari was incredible, wagyu steak and lobster was buttery and cooked PERFECT, blackberry cobbler was better than any cobbler I've ever had. Someone in our party got the halibut and if we werent leaving early tomorrow to go back home, I would have ordered one to go. ”
“ Honestly, just a fabulous meal from before I arrived until after I left. It was a special weekend with my birthday and my girlfriend’s birthday and a proposal. So many things. The chef made us a special appetizer, the halibut was flawless and the steak was perfectly crusted. The staff went above and beyond. Just a great night. While I am not from the island, I hope to return one day for another meal at McMillin’s Dining Room. ”
“ Wonderful birthday night. We dined at McMillin’s for a special celebration dinner. Leslie took fabulous care of us. We’re celebrating three birthdays in one night. Happy birthday to us. Thank you McMillins for a memorable dinner. ”
“ It is our first time to Roche Harbor and McMillin’s did not disappoint! Amy in the bar was fantastic. Our drinks were so delicious and the conversation was 10/10. Then we ate in the restaurant a couple of hours later and the service was above and beyond! Sarah completely took care of us from greeting us and suggesting a fabulous wine that was exactly what we were looking for to recommending a place for lunch the next day. One of our items did not come out as expected and she immediately took care of it with grace. I was so appreciative of her and we can’t wait to come back! ”
“ First time on the island - was told this was the spot for dinner -shout out to Taylor who made this experience amazing - from charging my phone, to chatting with me and answering all my silly questions about island living. Food selection was a little light. I had apps two crab cakes and brussels sprouts. Husband had meatloaf and mashed potatoes. Both meals were very tasty. Meatloaf was very tender! View was beautiful - plenty of wildlife to watch while enjoying your meal. Photo is a view from right near the restaurant. ”
“ Thanks to the staff we had a marvelous experience. They went out of their way for us. Beyond, of course the fabulous food! It's not always easy to please vegetarians and they did. So they volunteered to take photos of us, when we spilled a drink, no problem the gals completely changed the table cloth, wiped dry the table and reset everything in like 2 minutes! Then they helped us prank our friends, which was a big hit! And lucky for me it was Sunday Prime Rib special for dinner. Yummy. In case you had doubts about McMillin's! ”
“ We had dinner here while staying at the resort and it absolutely did not disappoint. Our server, Jodi, was a pleasure and provided us with the most excellent service. Everything we had here was delicious, the calamari really sticks out in mind as well as the fresh oysters. The view is absolutely stunning at sunset, so book your reservation for then if you can. This whole area is so special and charming that I hope it stays frozen in time forever. I will definitely dine here again the next time I am at the resort. ”
“ I hadn't been here in years, so when I came here to celebrate my engagement and birthday, I was hoping it would be just as good as I remember. Happy to report that from start to finish the experience was even better than I could have imagined. Friendly greeting at the door, a table with an incredible view overlooking the harbor, and promptly greeted by our server (gah I can't remember her name, but she was AMAZING). We had apps (crab bisque, beef empanadas), entrees (filet mignon, lamb chops), cocktails (pear martini, old fashioned), and dessert (cheesecake). Everything we ordered was beautifully plated, nicely cooked, and packed with flavor; Bill Shaw is a master of his craft. We were able to watch the sunset over the harbor (including the Colors ceremony) from our table. Our server even took us out to a deck to take photos of us. The whole experience was 10/10. Cannot recommend this place enough. ”